
Cloud Computing: A Financial Boon or Bane for Educational Institutes?


Jim Long, Director of IT, William Woods University
How do you see the benefits of cloud computing in the Education industry, and how have you embraced it?
For good or ill, there seems little doubt the cloud is here to stay. Vendors and educational institutions alike are moving to the cloud and, as with any new process or service, figuring out the details as they go. Are there benefits? Yes. Are there issues? Yes. Does it matter? Not really. Do you have a choice? Increasingly, no.
Vendors are moving to the cloud at an increasing rate. While the cloud may not have been specifically designed to change economic models, it certainly has. Led by industry juggernauts like Microsoft, vendors are changing their models and moving to the cloud. Rather than providing goods, they provide services. For a company like Microsoft, this makes a lot of sense. They achieve better license control, improved revenue, and better ability to plan with a cloud-based product like Office365. For vendors, therefore, the upside is very good, and they have multiple compelling reasons to change their sales model to a licensing model–and that is the fundamental shift, from selling to licensing.
Previously, most, if not all, software was sold by license, despite the illusion of a purchase. Whether you went to a big box store or ordered online, you purchased the software, installed it, and used it. Chances are, you clicked through the End User License Agreement (EULA) to get the install up and going as quickly as possible. These agreements were clear, as much as any contract could be, you were licensing the software without warranty and had no rights to the software itself. All well and good, as far as that went, because you could use the software to your heart’s content, be that six months or six years. Updates and the acquisition of newer versions were totally in your control. The software continued to open your files, enable editing, saving, and the typical things users like to do on their computers.
Failure to project future costs can lead to long-term financial problems
With the cloud, however, that model has changed. There is much more capability for a vendor to control its license. Sharing software is a thing of the past. Piracy can be better controlled or countered. As someone who previously financially relied on people actually purchasing the software I created, I believe this is a great thing. Everyone who uses the software actually has to pay for it. My creative efforts (and those of my colleagues) are appropriately rewarded. However, what about the other side of the equation?
As someone who has to license a growing catalog of software for the faculty, staff, and students of the university, the associated costs are potentially problematic. Gone are the days when we could license a specific version of a piece of software and use it as long as required. We were allowed to make the decision about whether to upgrade or make do with our current version, based on the priorities and budget of the institution. While the goal is always to have the latest and greatest, that is not always practical in the education industry. Sometimes we have to keep a specific version a bit longer than desired to have funds to purchase other software (or hardware). While I may initially pay less for a piece of software with the licensing model, keeping it for multiple years typically means I am paying much more over the life of the product than I did in the past.
Our institution has worked within the licensing model for many years. Much of our software, whether cloud-based or premises-based, is licensed. We are used to the model, in that we understand that the licensing costs will increase year over year. Now, a growing number of our critical applications are moving to the cloud and the licensing model is changing. How do we prepare for the change?
First and foremost, we must budget appropriately. While the cloud potentially saves in some areas, the license fee grows every non-contract year, typically by around 5 percent. When we budget, which is well in advance of the yearly cloud-based license invoice, we plan on an increase of 5 percent. While we are occasionally surprised (one way or another), this number is typically accurate. In practical terms, we request a 5 percent budget increase in our licensing budget, to stay even. For us, licensing is our second largest budget line item, after salary and benefits, so this is impactful and must be carefully considered.
Second, working closely with the president’s office and CFO, we must educate, so there is no sticker shock when others see the initial budget request. We are careful to plan for cost increases and examine whether we have alternatives–can we walk away from the license? Often this is not practical, even if it is possible. Can we really stop using Illustrator in the classroom when Adobe moves to the cloud? Our answer, this year, was no, we cannot. So, how do we budget for the increased costs?
Third, and finally, we work with vendors to maximize our budget and our options. What pricing choices do we have? What happens to the data if the license expires? Increasingly, we are finding the data is ours, but it is completely unusable, so we are now careful to plan an exit strategy for the license. While we may find we are constrained in our options regarding portions of the license, vendors are willing to work with us in other areas.
For all the technical benefits the cloud brings, there is bound to be a financial cost. It is becoming increasingly important to properly budget for that cost and carefully plan, not simply for the coming academic year, but years in the future, to appropriately understand the rise in expense associated with cloud-based licensing. With careful planning and vision, it is possible to maximize the benefits of the cloud without breaking the bank; however, failure to project future costs can lead to long-term financial problems.
ON THE DECK

Featured Vendors
K16 Solutions: Learning Management Systems (LMS) Migration Solutions, Created by Educators for Educators
Ask School Data (ASD): AI-Powered Virtual Data Coaching Solution that Provides Real-Time Student Data to Teachers
Liaison International: Streamlining the Enrollment Process with Institution-Wide Data and Responsive, Cross-Media Marketing
Education Networks of America (ENA): Turnkey Infrastructure Solutions Designed for K-12 Schools and Libraries
Verificient Technologies: Fostering Credibility for Online Education with Proctorless Remote Monitor
Huron Consulting Group: Helping Colleges and Universities better align Operations to achieve strateg
Cumulus Global: Helps Business, Schools, And Local Governments Achieve Their Goals By Leveraging The
LearningMate Solutions Inc.: Global Leader In Providing Content And Technology Services For The Educ
Globaloria: Invent. Build. Share: Advancing Computing Innovation And Digital Citizenship Skills Star
Cyanna Educational Services: Consultative Service For Top-Quality Schooling And Higher Education Sys
EDITOR'S PICK
Essential Technology Elements Necessary To Enable...
By Leni Kaufman, VP & CIO, Newport News Shipbuilding
Comparative Data Among Physician Peers
By George Evans, CIO, Singing River Health System
Monitoring Technologies Without Human Intervention
By John Kamin, EVP and CIO, Old National Bancorp
Unlocking the Value of Connected Cars
By Elliot Garbus, VP-IoT Solutions Group & GM-Automotive...
Digital Innovation Giving Rise to New Capabilities
By Gregory Morrison, SVP & CIO, Cox Enterprises
Staying Connected to Organizational Priorities is Vital...
By Alberto Ruocco, CIO, American Electric Power
Comprehensible Distribution of Training and Information...
By Sam Lamonica, CIO & VP Information Systems, Rosendin...
The Current Focus is On Comprehensive Solutions
By Sergey Cherkasov, CIO, PhosAgro
Big Data Analytics and Its Impact on the Supply Chain
By Pascal Becotte, MD-Global Supply Chain Practice for the...
Technology's Impact on Field Services
By Stephen Caulfield, Executive Director, Global Field...
Carmax, the Automobile Business with IT at the Core
By Shamim Mohammad, SVP & CIO, CarMax
The CIO's role in rethinking the scope of EPM for...
By Ronald Seymore, Managing Director, Enterprise Performance...
Driving Insurance Agent Productivity with Mobile and Big...
By Brad Bodell, SVP and CIO, CNO Financial Group, Inc.
Transformative Impact On The IT Landscape
By Jim Whitehurst, CEO, Red Hat
Get Ready for an IT Renaissance: Brought to You by Big...
By Clark Golestani, EVP and CIO, Merck
Four Initiatives Driving ECM Innovation
By Scott Craig, Vice President of Product Marketing, Lexmark...
Technology to Leverage and Enable
By Dave Kipe, SVP, Global Operations, Scholastic Inc.
By Meerah Rajavel, CIO, Forcepoint
AI is the New UI-AI + UX + DesignOps
By Amit Bahree, Executive, Global Technology and Innovation,...
Evolving Role of the CIO - Enabling Business Execution...
By Greg Tacchetti, CIO, State Auto Insurance
Read Also
How Digital Experience Is Of Growing Importance To P&C Insurers And...
What It Truly Means For IT Security To Bea Business Enabler
Digital Transformation 2 Requires a CIO v2.x
Leverage ChatGPT the Right Way through Well-Designed Prompts
Water Strategies for Climate Adaption
Policy is a Key Solution to Stopping Packaging Waste
